YouTube scrapes 2020 US election misinformation policy

YouTube will stop removing content that falsely claims the 2020 United States Presidential Election was plagued by “fraud, errors or glitches”, the platform said on Friday, a decision quickly criticised by anti-misinformation advocates.

The announcement by the Google-owned video website is a marked departure from its policy initiated in December 2020, which attempted to curb false claims – most importantly pushed by then-president Donald Trump – that his re-election loss to President Joe Biden was due to the vote being “stolen”.

“The ability to openly debate political ideas, even those that are controversial or based on disproven assumptions, is core to a functioning democratic society – especially in the midst of election season,” YouTube said in a blog post.

“We will stop removing content that advances false claims that widespread fraud, errors, or glitches occurred in the 2020 and other past US presidential elections.”

YouTube's updated policy, which goes into effect immediately, comes as tech platforms grapple with a key issue in America's hyperpolarised political environment: How to combat misinformation without curtailing free speech?

YouTube appeared to acknowledge that policing misinformation comes with downsides.

“Two years, tens of thousands of video removals, and one election cycle later, we recognised it was time to reevaluate the effects of this policy in today's changed landscape,” the video-sharing giant said.

“In the current environment, we find that while removing this content does curb some misinformation, it could also have the unintended effect of curtailing political speech without meaningfully reducing the risk of violence or other real-world harm.”

But that response prompted sharp criticism from US advocacy groups.

“YouTube is dead wrong in its assertion that removing false election content curtails political speech without meaningfully reducing real-world harms,” said Ms Nora Benavidez from the non-partisan group Free Press.

“Its dangerous decision to immediately stop removing content… which continues to sow hate and disinformation that threatens our democracy must be reversed immediately.”

YouTube insisted that its other existing rules against election misinformation remain unchanged, including its prohibition of content that deceives voters or incites people to interfere with democratic processes.

“YouTube was one of the last major social media platforms to keep in place a policy attempting to curb 2020 election misinformation,” said Ms Julie Millican, vice-president of the left-leaning watchdog Media Matters.

“Now, it's decided to take the easy way out by giving people like Donald Trump and his enablers free rein to continue to lie without consequence about the 2020 elections.”